They are reasonably priced compared to St. John. Everyone loves St. John where a nice 3 bed 3 bath villa with good access is worth 1.2 maybe a little less. For the same money you can get a real villa, like 5 beds and 5 baths on literally an estate. But it is hard to rent on St. Croix. The prices are coming down on all 3 of the U.S virgin islands but St. Croix is the one that you could name your price. St. Thomas is a more happening island however has an office max, a home depot, basically the states. The prices are dropping but not in the nice area. I just bought a villa in St. John and I payed 1.2 million and it is not hard to rent just for the mere fact that St. John is 2/3 National Forest. With the dollar weak, I would look at these 3 islands before Jost, Tortolla, and Norman.